A war

A war

DVD - 2016 | Danish
Average Rating:
Rate this:
12
4
1
Afghanistan. During a routine mission, soldiers are caught in heavy crossfire. Commander Claus makes a decision to save his men, which has grave consequences for him, and his family back home.
Publisher: [Los Angeles, California] : Magnolia Home Entertainment, ©2016.
Characteristics: 1 videodisc (116 min.) :,sound, color ;,12 cm
digital, optical, rda
videodisc
DVD
video file, DVD video, rda

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment
l
lavasushi
Feb 09, 2020

Such a fine line between murder and war in chaotic battles. To see the abuse and violation to citizens that are murdered by outlaws, and be tried for saving your comrades in a court that has never seen battle is preposterous. To see the family left behind struggling and facing a prison sentence that would exacerbate and intensify the breakdown is criminal. What a great film to show the fog of war.

k
kpelish
Aug 19, 2019

Extremely well-done and finely paced portrait of a Danish commander literally and figuratively under fire as he fights in the USA-led war against Taliban Afghanistan. The story graphically depicts the costs of war for both civilians and soldiers, exploring what loyalty is and what that might cost. The actress playing the commander's wife also shows the difficulties of managing home life without a spouse. In Danish with English subtitles.

r
richibi
Dec 13, 2018

a family adjusts to a soldier's mission in Afghanistan, with all its nefarious consequences - shot with hand-held cameras, like a home movie, but more probing - in real time, it can get tedious, even maudlin - see "Brothers" instead, an utter masterpiece by another Danish director, on the same subject

a
akirakato
Dec 11, 2017

This is a 2015 Danish war drama written and directed by Tobias Lindholm.
It depicts the story of a Danish military company in Afghanistan that fights the Taliban while trying to protect the civilians.
The commander gets, however, accused of having committed a war crime.
Then follows a court drama.
It’s a riveting, complicated court case that asks you simple question: what do you do when there’s no right answer?

f
fdb045
Jul 19, 2017

Note - this movie is not entertainment nor "Hollywood".
It is very well done protraying the reality of modern war. It seems like a documentary if you didn't know better.

r
Ron@Ottawa
May 07, 2017

This film from Denmark consists of two chapters, the first from the battle field in Afghanistan and the second from the court room where the protagonist, a commander, was charged with war crime. The small-scale battles were done well, and the court room drama engaging. But I find the side scenes of family dialogues unnecessary and distracting. The theme is about the morality of war, and how one single decision, made in a split second, justified or not, can result in the loss of lives of many civilians. Subtitles.

n
Nursebob
Apr 20, 2017

Impeccably acted and effectively shot with either manic handheld cameras while under siege or slow domestic pans, Lindholm’s battlefield allegory certainly showcases the contradiction of “ethical warfare”, yet its deeper questions go beyond the battlefield. Truth is often what we make of it—indeed, Pedersen’s trial receives an unexpected and morally problematic upset—and sometimes the rules really shouldn’t apply as a lesser but equally momentous decision on Claus’ part reveals when an Afghan family seeks sanctuary at his camp. Subtle metaphors abound—a soccer ball here, a child’s duvet there—and Lindholm ends it all with an enigmatic silence that rings louder than mortar shells.

e
empbee
Mar 18, 2017

Very good movie about the cruelty of war, its innocent victims; hard instant decisions, ethical issues about truth, memory, the logic of the written law and the possible consequences.

ArapahoeLarissa Dec 07, 2016

One of those best movies about true war.

d
DHahn
Aug 16, 2016

The quagmire of Afghanistan and how it affects the soldiers and families examined with deep precision by this very compelling film. Civilian deaths, soldiers placed between savage ambush and the politicians "rules of engagement," and deteriorating family lives at home. Many of these issues of Denmark will strike a chord in the US. An excellent and smart film.

View All Comments

Notices

Add Notices
k
kpelish
Aug 19, 2019

Other: Minor sexism. Only one female soldier is shown; a poor throw is characterized as "throwing like a girl".

k
kpelish
Aug 19, 2019

Frightening or Intense Scenes: War battles. Long build-up of sighting a target for death by a Danish sniper.

k
kpelish
Aug 19, 2019

Violence: Graphic wounds (a soldier is shown with his legs blown off) and deaths of an innocent family/children.

k
kpelish
Aug 19, 2019

Coarse Language: Swearing in Danish.

Quotes

Add a Quote
j
jimg2000
Jun 29, 2016

Those military alphabets:
“pax,” passengers/people
“9-line medevac,” Calling in a combat injury
“SITREP,” situation report
“HLS,” Homeland Security or Handheld Laser Scanner
“RPG,” Rocket propelled grenade
“TOC,” tactical op center
“PID,” positive i.d.
===
If Danish soldiers, who put their lives one the line, are prosecuted for violations of the military
criminal code, on conjecture, THEN we'll be somewhere, we do not want to be.
===
But although we have sympathy for the defendant, who appears to be a competent soldier and leader and although we must provide Danish soldiers room for maneuverability in extreme circumstances. No one is above the law. Otherwise, a judicial system is rendered superfluous. If we in a case like this let such a serious violation of humanitarian rights slide, we will end somewhere, where we do not want to be.
===
-What the hell was I supposed to do?
-Huh? It's not about what you were supposed to do, but what you do right now.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at Library

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top